Why don’t you give me anything you could say about this male petty that approached you guys? Okay.

He was like a man little bit.

He had like a for like nylon thing or the mask.

You know what color it was? He grabbed Jacob and then he told me to run as fast as I could into the woods or else he’d shoot.

Three boys rode their bikes to a convenience store.

Only two of them came home.

On what should have been a quiet, ordinary night in rural Minnesota, a single moment turned into the most influential criminal case in the state’s history.

One that would ultimately reshape laws across the United States.

11-year-old Jacob Wetling was reported abducted.

Hundreds of suspects were investigated.

More than a thousand volunteers joined the search.

Over 70,000 tips were logged.

And yet, for 27 years, the case remained silent.

The breakthrough came from an attack that had happened just 9 months earlier.

A strikingly similar crime involving another boy who survived.

How could such a clear connection remain hidden for nearly three decades? We’re unraveling a mystery that stumped investigators for a generation.

What makes Jacob’s disappearance so infuriating is that the monster responsible was never truly missing.

His name had been on the police’s radar from the very first days of the investigation.

His shoes matched the prints.

His tires matched the tracks.

Yet, in a series of baffling oversightes, he was brushed aside, allowed to live in freedom for decades, while the investigation chased ghosts and ruined the lives of innocent men.

But while the official search stalled, Jacob’s mother, Patty Wetling, turned her grief into a relentless crusade.

For 27 agonizing years, she refused to let her son’s name fade into a statistic.

Her tireless fight didn’t just keep the case alive.

It changed the face of American justice forever.

Her persistence forced the United States to enact a landmark federal law establishing the first national registry for those who pray on children, ensuring that Jacob’s legacy would protect every child in the nation.

How did a killer hide in plain sight for nearly three decades? Why did it take another victim’s courage to finally break the silence? Today, we go back to that quiet October night in 1989.

We will trace the missed leads, the decades of heartbreak, and the final chilling confession that brought a lost son home.

Where are you watching from today? Drop your location in the comments.

It’s powerful to see how far Jacob’s story travels and how it continues to connect us all even decades later.

This is a story of a mother’s iron will, a systems failure, and a truth that waited 10,000 days to be told.

But before this story reshaped American law and haunted a generation of parents, it began in a place where nothing like this was supposed to happen.

St.Joseph, Minnesota in the late 1980s was a small rural community of roughly 2,500 people defined by a deep and unshakable sense of safety.

The town’s police chief did not even feel the need to carry a firearm, reflecting the community’s profound trust in its own security.

On the rural outskirts of this town lived the Wetling family.

Their home sat at the end of a quiet culde-sac surrounded by corn fields, thick bushes, and clusters of trees where neighbors were separated by long dirt roads and wide open land.

Jacob Wetling was born on February 17th, 1978.

He was the son of Patty and Jerry Wetling, growing up alongside his siblings Amy, Trevor, and Carmen.

Jacob was an 11-year-old sixth grader known for his gentle and sweet disposition.

He was a boy who deeply enjoyed the staples of a Minnesota childhood, playing hockey and basketball while harboring a significant passion for watching football.

He had simple, clear preferences.

His favorite food was steak.

His favorite color was blue.

And his absolute favorite pastime was watching a game on television.

The day of October 22nd, 1989 unfolded with the rhythm of a perfect autumn Sunday.

It began early when Jacob and Jerry went fishing, an activity Jacob cherished.

They returned to the house in time to settle in for the Minnesota Vikings matchup against the Detroit Lions.

Later that afternoon, the family went indoor ice skating.

It was a day filled with the activities Jacob loved most, providing no hint of the tragedy that loomed.

Patty and Jerry had a dinner engagement with friends that evening.

Around 5:30 p.

m.

, they departed for the gathering, which was located about 25 mi, roughly 32 km away.

They expected the drive to take approximately 25 minutes.

Because they did not intend to be out late, and because there was no school the following day, they felt comfortable leaving the older children at home.

Amy, the eldest, was staying at a friend’s house for the night.

This left 8-year-old Carmen, 10-year-old Trevor, and 11-year-old Jacob at the residence.

Jacob’s friend, 11-year-old Aaron Leil, was also there to spend the night.

As the three boys shared a pizza, they decided they wanted to rent a movie from the local Tom Thumb store located a 15-minute bike ride from the house.

They called their mother to ask for permission to make the trip.

Patty’s response was immediate and firm.

She said, “Absolutely not.

” Unwilling to accept the refusal, Trevor asked to speak with his father, hoping for a different outcome.

Jerry listened to the boys and ultimately overruled Patty’s decision.

He told the boys they could go, but he set specific conditions intended to ensure their safety.

They had to take a flashlight with them and wear a reflective vest so that any passing motorists would be able to see them in the darkness.

This decision, born of a father’s desire to let his children enjoy a small measure of independence, would later become one of the most agonizing memories for the family.

Not wanting to leave 8-year-old Carmen home alone, the boys contacted their 14-year-old neighbor, Rochelle.

She agreed to come over and watch Carmen while the boys were away.

Jacob gathered the necessary items, securing a flashlight and the reflective vest his father had insisted upon.

The three boys, Jacob, Trevor, and Aaron, then set out on their bicycles, pedalling toward the Tom Thumb.

On the way to the store, they heard a rustling sound coming from the corn fields or the long grass lining the road.

They didn’t give it much thought, assuming it was merely an animal or the wind, and they continued their ride.

They arrived at the Tom Thumb and selected the movie The Naked Gun.

After spending a short time there, they began the return trip home.

The sky was profoundly dark as the three boys began the 15-minute journey back to the culde-sac.

As they pedled away from the Tom Thumb, the familiar lights of the town began to fade behind them, eventually vanishing altogether.

They entered a rural stretch where no street lights guided their path.

The only illumination in the void was the single flashlight Jacob carried.

They were roughly 2 to three minutes away from the safety of the Wetterling house, nearing a long gravel driveway, when a man suddenly emerged from the shadows and walked toward them.

He was dressed entirely in black and wore a black mask over his face.

He announced that he had a gun and commanded the boys to stop.

The man ordered them to put their bicycles into a ditch and then instructed the boys to get into the ditch themselves lying face down on the ground.

At first the boys struggled to grasp the gravity of the situation, wondering if perhaps this was an elaborate prank being played on them by older kids.

That illusion was shattered when the man began to speak and interact with them in a chilling, raspy voice.

He approached Trevor first and asked how old he was.

When Trevor replied that he was 10, the man told him to get up and run into the bushes as fast as he could.

He warned Trevor not to look back, threatening that if he did, he would be shot.

Once Trevor had fled into the darkness, the man turned his attention to Jacob and Aaron, ordering them both to stand.

As he held them there, he began groping and fondling Jacob, his hands moving over the boy’s body.

While doing this, he continued his interrogation.

He asked Aaron his age, and Aaron replied that he was 11.

He then asked Jacob his age, and Jacob also answered that he was 11.

The man then issued the same command to Aaron that he had given to Trevor.

He told the boy to run into the woods as fast as he could and reiterated that he would shoot him if he looked back.

Aaron bolted into the darkness, running with such frantic speed that he eventually caught up with Trevor.

Once they were together, the impulse to look back became overwhelming.

When they finally turned their heads to see what had become of their friend, both Jacob and the masked man had vanished.

There was no sign of a struggle, no sound of a vehicle, and no indication of where they had gone.

It was approximately 9:20 p.

m.

the moment Jacob Wetling was seen for the final time.

Trevor and Aaron reached the Wetling house in a state of sheer terror.

Their screams alerting Rochelle that something had gone terribly wrong.

They cried out that someone had taken Jacob, that he was simply gone.

Rochelle, overwhelmed and uncertain of how to handle the crisis, ran next door to find her father, Mel Drew Zach.

Mel immediately grasped the urgency and called Patty and Jerry at the dinner party.

He told them they needed to return home instantly, explaining that while the details were unclear, Jacob had been taken by a stranger.

After hanging up with the Wetterlings, Mel dialed 911.

Because he had not been a witness to the abduction, he struggled to convey the specifics to the dispatcher, eventually putting Trevor on the phone to explain what had happened.

Trevor described a man with a raspy voice who was short and stocky.

The emergency call recorded the frantic atmosphere as the neighbors and the boys tried to provide descriptions.

Jacob had been wearing a red jacket with metal buttons and a police department emblem, the reflective vest, and was carrying the flashlight.

The dispatcher questioned if they had seen a vehicle, but the boys could only report that the man had appeared on foot on the road.

When the first police officers arrived at the Veterling home, the investigation began with a significant error in judgment.

Rather than immediately launching a pursuit, the officers spent the most crucial minutes of the disappearance questioning Trevor and Aaron with a high degree of skepticism.

They did not initially believe the account of an abduction, instead entertaining theories that the boys might have been playing with a firearm and accidentally shot Jacob, or that Jacob had simply run away and his friends were providing a cover story to give him a head start.

It was not until 10:45 p.

m.

, nearly 90 minutes after the abduction had occurred, that a formal search was initiated.

By this time, the window of opportunity to catch the kidnapper in the immediate area had significantly narrowed.

Law enforcement eventually mobilized a sizable force, including firefighters, volunteers, and helicopters.

Despite the scale of the effort, the searchers found only two physical clues near the gravel driveway.

A set of footprints and tire tracks.

Curiously, in the haste and confusion of the night, the officers failed to canvas the immediate neighbors for information.

They did not even seek out Dan Rasier, an elementary school music teacher who lived at the very end of the long gravel driveway where the abduction had taken place.

Earlier that evening around 900 p.

m.

Dan had been home alone when he heard his dog Smirky barking.

Looking out the window, he had seen headlights moving down his driveway.

The vehicle eventually turned around and left, an event Dan dismissed before going back to bed.

Later, he was woken again by Smirky’s barking.

This time, looking out, he saw several men with flashlights moving around his wood pile.

Fearing that people were attempting to steal his firewood, he prepared to confront them.

But seeing their numbers, he decided to stay inside and call 911.

The dispatcher informed him that the men were police officers conducting a search.

Dan went outside to offer his assistance, suggesting they look around his farm buildings and other local properties, but the officers did not take the opportunity to formally question him about what he had seen earlier that night.

By the following morning, the news of the abduction had rippled through the community of St.

Joseph and the town transformed as residents mobilized to help.

The media coverage grew exponentially, turning the disappearance of Jacob Wetling into a story of national interest.

The Wetling home became a hub of constant activity with hundreds of officers from various jurisdictions, including the FBI and the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, establishing a presence.

In the week following the disappearance, the search efforts reached a staggering scale.

Thousands of volunteers formed a human chain that stretched down the main road while law enforcement deployed blood hounds, helicopters, and ATVs to scour the more rural and rugged terrain.

Some officers searched on horseback, but despite the massive mobilization and the thousands of hours logged, no trace of Jacob was found.

Patty and Jerry Wetling committed themselves to keeping Jacob’s name in the public consciousness, participating in media interviews almost every single day.

In one interview with the St.

Cloud Times, Jerry spoke with raw remorse.

I’ll carry this for the rest of my life.

I’m the one who made the choice that night, and my son never came home.

If anyone has any information about Jacob, please come forward.

I would give anything, pay any price, just to bring my son home.

They hoped that a constant media presence would generate the one lead necessary to bring their son home.

Over the years, the investigation would amass approximately 70,000 leads, each of which was documented and followed by investigators.

Every year on Jacob’s birthday, Patty and Jerry established a heartbreaking ritual.

They lit a candle on a cupcake in his honor, holding on to the hope that he would eventually return to blow it out.

They also kept a porch light burning every night, a silent signal to Jacob that the way home was always open.

The years that followed passed without a breakthrough, and the anniversaries of his disappearance became the only markers of time.

During the annual prayer service on October 22nd, 1994, Evangelene, a former high school friend of Patty, who was now living in Little Falls, Minnesota, attended the gathering.

The two women had lost contact many years earlier, their lives having moved in different directions after graduation.

Evangelene had recognized Patty’s name only because her son’s case had appeared so frequently in the newspapers over the last 5 years.

For that reason, she had deliberately traveled to St.

Joseph and attended Jacob’s prayer service with the specific hope of seeing Patty again.

The atmosphere inside St.

Joseph Catholic Church was heavy with the collective grief of a community that had been waiting half a decade for answers.

During the prayer service, Evangelene happened to look toward the altar and recognized a familiar face.

The man presiding over the ceremony was associate priest Damian Burke.

She watched him closely as he moved through the liturgy, her recognition of him growing more certain with every passing minute.

Shortly after the service ended and the parishioners began to disperse, Evangelene found Patty.

After the initial emotional reconnection between the two old friends, Evangelene asked Patty whether she knew anything about the background of Damian Burke.

Patty replied that Damen had been transferred to St.

Joseph Catholic Church a few years earlier, though as she searched her memory, she admitted she could not remember the exact date of his arrival.

She confessed that she knew very little about his life or his previous assignments before he joined their parish.

Evangelene then shared a story that left Patty visibly shaken.

She explained that before his transfer to St.

Joseph, Damian Burke had been a newly ordained priest at St.

Francis Church in Little Falls.

According to Evangelene, Damian had been involved in a very serious offense that resulted in him being demoted and reassigned to another parish.

The parishioners at St.

Francis were kept in the dark about the details of his departure and were never told where he had been sent.

The incident Evangelene referred to involved the alleged sexual abuse of a 13-year-old male parishioner.

At the time, the boy’s family had reported the matter to both the local police and the church hierarchy.

Yet, the situation had faded away without a public explanation.

Neither the victim’s family nor the members of the St.

Francis Parish ever spoke of it again, and Damian was officially informed of his demotion and subsequent transfer.

Persistent rumors had circulated in Little Falls that Damian was the nephew of a highranking official within the Dascese of St.

Cloud, and many believed the case had been quietly settled behind closed doors to avoid a public scandal.

Following this conversation, Patty began to look into the timing of the priest’s arrival.

She discovered that Damen Burke had been assigned to St.

Joseph Catholic Church just 6 months before Jacob went missing.

Overwhelmed by the implications of this timing, she immediately shared everything she had learned with Jerry.

Jerry promptly took the information to the local police, hoping it would spark a new direction in the investigation.

However, police chief Robert Harrove dismissed the suggestion.

He told Jerry that the suspicion was unfounded and based on hearsay, stating firmly that he could not authorize an investigation into a member of the clergy based on such claims.

During the mid 1990s, the Catholic Church and its priests still held immense social and moral influence within American communities, particularly in small towns like St.

Joseph.

To suspect a parochial vicor of such a crime was considered socially unacceptable, and law enforcement was conditioned to tread with extreme caution when dealing with accusations involving the church.

The matter remained stagnant until 1996 when Jerry and Patty learned that Damen Burke was once again preparing to be transferred, this time to a new position within the Dascese of St.

Cloud.

The news that he might leave the area without being questioned reignited Jerry’s fierce determination.

He approached Chief Hargrove a second time, pleading for the priest to be looked into before he moved, but the response remained the same.

There was no evidence to justify an inquiry.

With the official channels closed to him, Jerry turned to the community.

He began reaching out to friends and neighbors, sharing his suspicions about the priest’s background and asking for their support in demanding answers.

His persistence resonated with the town’s people, and eventually he gathered more than 1,000 signatures from local residents who wanted the matter settled.

Jerry submitted the petition to the Sterns County Sheriff’s Office.

The document did not explicitly accuse Damian Burke of abducting Jacob.

Instead, it formally requested that investigators review any possible connection the priest might have had to the case on the night of the disappearance.

After a month of consideration and under the pressure of a thousand local voices, the Sterns County Sheriff’s Office decided to open an official investigation into parochial vicor Damian Burke.

Detective Paul McCarthy was assigned to lead the investigation.

One of his first actions was to submit a formal request to the Morrison County Sheriff’s Office for any records related to the alleged sexual assault involving the 13-year-old boy in Little Falls.

The response McCarthy received was unexpected and troubling.

There was no record of such a case ever having existed in their files.

It was as if the report had never been made.

Despite the lack of paperwork, Damen Burke was summoned for questioning.

During his interview with Detective McCarthy, Damian stated that on the night of October 22nd, 1989, he had remained at St.

Joseph Catholic Church for the entire evening.

However, when McCarthy attempted to verify this, he found that no one was able to corroborate the priest’s alibi.

Damian had been alone in his residence for the hours in question.

Detective McCarthy then requested that Damian submit to a polygraph test.

Damian eventually agreed, but the results indicated deception.

He failed the examination.

When confronted with the results, Damian explained them away by claiming that the events of 1989 were too far in the past and that his memory of that specific night was unclear, which he suggested caused his physiological distress during the test.

Without physical evidence or a confession, the sheriff’s office had no grounds to hold him and Damian was released.

In a further attempt to find clarity, Detective McCarthy later played an audio recording of Damian’s statement to Trevor, who was 16 years old at the time.

McCarthy watched the teenager closely, hoping for a definitive reaction that would break the case wide open.

After listening to the recording multiple times, Trevor told the detective that Damen’s voice sounded very similar to the raspy voice of the man who had stopped them on the gravel driveway 5 years earlier.

However, the weight of the moment and the passage of time meant he could not be completely certain.

This inconclusive identification only served to deepen the investigators suspicions, leaving them with a mounting sense of unease about the priest.

At the time, Damian Burke was widely respected within St.

Joseph, seen as a pillar of the community, second only to Father Hans M.

Olsen.

Consequently, the investigation into the priest provoked an intense and bitter backlash from a segment of the local Catholic community.

Supporters of Damian Burke began to call for the social isolation of the Wetling family.

A counter petition was even submitted to the bishop demanding that he impose excommunication on Jerry and Patty for what the signers described as a serious act of sacrilege against a servant of the church.

Despite the immense pressure and the hostility from some of their neighbors, Jerry and Patty refused to abandon their pursuit of the truth.

Their sole purpose remained finding justice for their son, regardless of the social cost.

In the midst of this tension, Father Hans M.

Olsen wrote a formal letter of character reference to the Sterns County Sheriff’s Office.

He vouched for Damian’s moral character in the strongest possible terms, affirming that he was a good man who had served the church with total faithfulness.

With the church hierarchy firmly behind him and no direct physical evidence linking him to the gravel driveway, the investigation into parochial vicor Damian Burke stalled.

The files were put away, leaving the question of his involvement and the truth about his time in Little Falls shrouded in an unresolved silence.

The trajectory of the investigation shifted significantly in 2004.

John Sanner had been elected as the Sterns County Sheriff and he made a public vow to exhaust every resource to solve the Wetling case.

Sanner and his team began to re-evaluate the evidence, moving away from the 14-year-old assumption that the abductor had utilized a vehicle.

They developed a new theory.

The abduction had been carried out on foot.

This shift was significant because it suggested that the perpetrator was someone who lived in very close proximity to the gravel driveway.

Consequently, the investigation turned its full focus toward Dan Rasier.

This change in theory was driven largely by the belated account of a man named Kevin.

On the night of the abduction in 1989, Kevin and his girlfriend had been listening to a police scanner and heard the initial reports about a missing boy in St.

Joseph.

Driven by curiosity, they drove to the area to see the situation for themselves.

They turned down the gravel driveway, performed a U-turn, and spotted the boy’s bicycles in the ditch.

They briefly considered picking the bikes up, but ultimately decided against it and drove away.

As they were leaving, they encountered a police officer in a parking lot and attempted to report what they had seen, but the officer dismissed their information.

Kevin had shared this story casually at parties for years as an icebreaker until 2003 when he told it to a person who happened to be a federal marshal.

The marshall urged him to provide a formal statement to law enforcement.

To Sheriff Sanders’s team, Kevin’s story provided a convenient explanation for both the car Dan Riier had seen in his driveway and the tire tracks found at the scene, effectively removing the car element from the crime.

For the next several years, investigators dedicated their efforts to building a case against Dan Rasier.

This culminated on June 30th, 2010, when a massive task force consisting of the Sterns County Sheriff’s Office, FBI agents, and state crime investigators arrived to execute an intensive search of his property.

The search lasted for 2 days and was a major media event.

News helicopters circled overhead, broadcasting images of investigators excavating a specific area at the back of the property where Dan and his family had historically dumped ashes from their wood burning stove.

The public nature of this search effectively ruined Dan Rasier’s life.

His face was broadcast across the country as the primary suspect in the veterling abduction and for the next 15 years he lived under a cloud of suspicion and hostility.

An elementary school music teacher who lived with his elderly parents, Dan maintained his innocence throughout the ordeal.

Despite repeated complaints about his treatment and the psychological toll of the investigation, the pressure never eased.

He had always tried to cooperate with authorities, yet he remained their singular focus.

For years, the investigation stayed fixed on Dan Rasier.

Leads were exhausted, time passed, and still the case refused to move forward.

What investigators did not fully understand at the time was that the answer they were searching for had already surfaced briefly, quietly, before Jacob ever disappeared.

It existed in a separate report filed months earlier involving a different boy who had survived an encounter disturbingly similar to Jacobs.

That boy was Jared Shy.

Jared was 12 years old on the night of January 13th, 1989, just 9 months before Jacob Wetling vanished.

He lived in Cold Spring, a small town only a short distance from St.

Joseph.

At the time, his case was treated as an isolated incident.

In hindsight, it was anything but.

On the evening of his abduction, Jared had been ice skating with his friends, after which they visited a small local establishment called the Side Cafe.

Eventually, Jared and his friend Corey began the walk home together, but they reached a point where they had to part ways.

As Jared continued the walk alone, a man in a blue car pulled up beside him and asked for directions.

The man then exited the vehicle and informed Jared that he had a gun and was not afraid to use it, commanding the boy to get into the car.

Jared followed the instructions, climbing into the back seat and lying face down as ordered.

The man told him to place a hat over his head to obscure his vision.

As they drove, Jared listened to the sounds of a police scanner coming from the front of the car, a device similar to the one used by Kevin and his girlfriend on the night of Jacob’s disappearance.

Jared attempted to keep track of their movements as the man drove for 10 to 15 minutes.

They crossed over sets of train tracks, but eventually Jared lost his sense of direction.

The car finally came to a stop on a remote gravel road.

The man climbed into the back seat and sexually assaulted Jared.

Afterward, he drove Jared back toward town, dropping him off about 2 minutes away from his home.

He gave Jared the same chilling ultimatum that Trevor and Aaron would hear months later.

Run away as fast as possible and do not look back or be shot.

He added a final threat, vowing that if anyone came looking for him or found out who he was, he would find Jared and kill him.

The case remained stagnant for decades until Jared Shy, now an adult, took matters into his own hands.

After moving to the town of Payneesville, Jared began hearing about a series of sexually assaulted that had occurred there.

He started to connect the dots in his own mind, suspecting that his own abduction, Jacob’s disappearance, and the crimes in Payneesville were the work of the same man.

Jared sought out the other victims in Payneesville, and together they contacted the investigators assigned to the Wetling case.

This renewed interest led investigators to re-examine the physical evidence they had preserved for decades.

Crucially, law enforcement still possessed the clothing Jared had been wearing on the night of his 1989 abduction, and they also had the hat they had taken from Danny Heinrich during the initial investigation.

Advances in forensic technology allowed for a DNA comparison that had been impossible 27 years earlier.

The results provided a definitive match revealing the identity of the man who had been hiding in the system for 27 years, Danny Heinrich.

At the time, Heinrich was a 53-year-old single man residing in Anandale, Minnesota.

For years, he had lived quietly, drawing little attention, his name long buried among hundreds of tips and potential suspects generated in the early days of the investigation.

Heinrich had actually been the very first suspect questioned in the early days of the 1989 investigation.

He had been released then, but decades later, DNA evidence finally provided the link law enforcement had missed, connecting him to the abduction and sexual assault of Jared Shy.

In the initial 1989 investigation into Jacob’s disappearance, police had looked into Heinrich because of the similarities between the cases.

Heinrich had been cooperative at the time, providing hair samples, his shoes, and even allowing his tires to be examined.

While investigators noted that his shoes and tires were a close match to the footprints and tracks found at the Wetling crime scene, they concluded the evidence was not definitive enough for a sure thing.

They maintained surveillance on him for weeks and eventually obtained a search warrant for his father’s house where he was living.

During that search, officers found several items of interest, including black boots, a pair of hammer pants, and police scanners.

They also discovered several locked trunks.

Inside these trunks were two photographs.

One depicted a boy in his underwear, and the other showed a boy wearing only a towel as he emerged from a shower.

Heinrich insisted to the officers that the images were innocent and not what they appeared to be.

In a decision that would later be viewed with intense scrutiny, the investigators allowed him to keep the photographs, which he eventually burned.

Lacking what they felt was sufficient evidence for a charge at the time, the police released him.

Decades later, that missed opportunity would come into sharp focus.

However, a significant legal hurdle immediately emerged.

Despite the DNA evidence proving Heinrich’s guilt in the 1989 attack, the statute of limitations for that specific crime had already expired.

This meant that the state could not legally charge him for the abduction and sexual assault of Jared Shy.

While this realization was a source of immense frustration for the families and investigators, the DNA match provided the necessary legal standing to obtain a new search warrant for Hinrich’s current residence.

On July 28th, 2015, investigators descended on Hinrich’s home.

Inside a kitchen drawer, they found duct tape and handcuffs.

They also discovered four large bins filled with boys clothing.

Perhaps most disturbing were the numerous VHS tapes Heinrich had recorded over the course of more than a decade.

These tapes contained footage he had filmed of young boys.

Additionally, the search yielded 19 binders filled with child pornography.

Based on this evidence, Heinrich was arrested and charged with 25 counts related to the possession and receipt of child pornography.

Heinrich spent nearly a year in jail awaiting his trial.

Three weeks before the proceedings were scheduled to begin, his legal team proposed a plea deal that would finally provide the Veterling family with the answers they had sought for 27 years.

The terms of the deal were that if Hinrich provided a full and detailed confession to the abduction and murder of Jacob Veterling and led authorities to his remains, he would not be charged with the murder itself.

Instead, he would plead guilty to a single count of possession of child pornography, which carried a maximum sentence of 17 to 20 years.

For Patty and Jerry Wetling, the desire for closure and the need to bring their son home outweighed the desire for a longer sentence, and they agreed to the arrangement.

Heinrich’s subsequent confession was cold and methodical, finally shattering the lingering hope the family had nurtured for nearly three decades.

He recounted how on the night of October 22nd, 1989, he had been driving aimlessly around St.

Joseph.

He had turned down the deadend road leading to the Wetling house and spotted three boys making their way into town.

He decided to park his vehicle near the gravel driveway and wait for their return.

As Trevor and Aaron had correctly described, he confronted them as they biked home, forced them into the ditch, and eventually selected Jacob.

He handcuffed the boy and placed him in the front passenger seat of his car.

As Hinrich drove away, Jacob was crying, repeatedly, asking what he had done wrong.

Heinrich had a police scanner in the vehicle, and as he began to hear an increase in radio activity, he realized the search for the boy was already mobilizing.

He commanded Jacob to lean down low in the front passenger seat so that they would not be spotted by any passing patrols.

He drove around the roads of St.

Joseph for a period of time before eventually heading toward Payneesville, the town where he lived.

He eventually pulled off onto a side road near a gravel pit and ordered Jacob to get out of the car.

He removed the handcuffs and then commanded the boy to undress.

In the isolation of the gravel pit, Heinrich sexually assaulted Jacob.

Afterward, the boy began to cry, shivering in the night air and stating that he was cold and simply wanted to go home.

Heinrich told him to get back into his clothes.

As Jacob was dressing, a patrol car drove by the area.

While the officers were not actually searching that specific road for the boy at that moment, the sight of the police lights caused Hinrich to panic.

He believed the authorities were closing in on him.

He told Jacob to turn around and then attempted to shoot him.

The gun jammed on the first attempt, but as Jacob stood there in terror, Hinrich cleared the chamber and fired a second time.

Jacob fell to the ground.

Heinrich initially left the body there and went home, but he returned a few hours later with a shovel.

He found that he could not dig a hole deep enough by hand, so he walked to a nearby construction site and took a bobcat.

He used the heavy machinery to dig a grave and bury Jacob, later returning the bobcat to the site where he had found it.

He tried to obscure the grave by covering it with a small amount of grass.

Before leaving, he realized he had forgotten to bury the boy’s shoes, so he took them and threw them into a nearby ravine.

Approximately a year later, Heinrich returned to the site and decided to move the remains.

He transported them to a nearby cow pasture and buried them in a hole about 2 ft deep.

When Danny Heinrich finally led investigators to the location 27 years later, the technology of metal detectors proved unnecessary.

They had intended to search for the metal buttons on Jacob’s red jacket, but instead they found a small weathered piece of red fabric sticking out of the ground.

It had remained there, partially exposed to the elements through decades of Minnesota seasons, while the world moved on, and the search continued elsewhere.

The recovery of those remains systematically dismantled the fragile hope that Patty and Jerry Wetling had tended for 10,000 days.

The ritual of the birthday cupcake, the single candle lit every February 17th, was finally over.

The porch light that had burned every night as a beacon for a lost son was extinguished, replaced by the heavy reality of his fate.

The family was forced to reconcile the sweet boy they remembered with the knowledge that Jacob’s last words were a question of his own innocence, asking what he had done wrong.

The legal resolution of the case brought its own form of bitterness.

Due to the expiration of statutes of limitations, Heinrich walked away without a murder conviction.

His sentence tied instead to the child pornography found in his home.

This legal frustration served as a retrospective catalyst for the work Patty Wetling had already begun years earlier.

Refusing to let her son be remembered only as a victim, she had transformed her grief into a formidable political force.

During the decades when Jacob was still missing, Patty had lobbied tirelessly in Washington DC, leading to the Jacob Wetling Crimes against children and sexually violent offender registration act signed into law by President Bill Clinton in 1994.

This landmark legislation was the first of its kind, requiring all states to establish registries for those who commit crimes against children.

Before this law, a predator could move across state lines and vanish into a new community without oversight.

Jacob’s law ended that anonymity.

It paved the way for Megan’s law in 1996, fundamentally shifting the balance of power from the privacy of the offender to the safety of the neighborhood.

The Wetling’s advocacy ensured that the sense of safety lost in St.

Joseph would be replaced by a new national framework of vigilance, giving American parents the legal right to know if a person with a history of predatory behavior lived on their block.

In an interview following Jacob’s funeral, Patty Wetling spoke through tears.

“My little boy is finally home,” she said.

“I am deeply grateful for the dedication and persistence of law enforcement who never gave up on Jacob.

” She also took a moment to acknowledge the painful consequences the investigation had carried for others, expressing regret toward those who had been publicly suspected over the years and whose reputations had been deeply affected by the long search for answers.

The conclusion of the Wetling case did more than close a file.

It permanently altered the landscape of childhood in America.

Yet for the community of St.

Joseph.

The legacy remained a permanent loss of the security that once allowed children to ride their bikes at night.

As investigators stood over the site Heinrich had identified, the sheer proximity of the truth was the most difficult detail to reconcile.

They had spent decades following 70,000 leads, utilizing everything from helicopters to blood hounds.

Yet throughout all those years, a small weathered fragment of Jacob’s jacket had remained at the burial site.

For 27 years, that little piece of red fabric had been resting in plain sight in the grass of the cow pasture.

And for 27 years, nobody had found him.

Thanks for being here and listening.

Don’t forget to hit the bell for our latest stories.

Stay safe and take care with your loved ones.